Scali:
Scali, take two. First of all I want to state that I'm an
accident of history. Without seeking to, I became directly involved in the
settlement of the Cuban Missile Crisis, a role that turned out to be
historic but which at the time just added to the confusion because I was
covering this crisis full-time. My role began on a Friday afternoon, the
fourth day of the crisis, when I received a telephone call about one-thirty
in the afternoon. I was munching on a boloney sandwich at that time, which
was to be my lunch for the day. I recognized the man on the phone
immediately as the Embassy counselor of the Soviet Embassy. He ah—asked for
us to have lunch immediately so we could discuss an important matter. I was
about to tell him that I'd already had lunch. It was namely the sandwich in
my hand, when he added that it was very important and that ah, could I
possibly find the time. I felt that perhaps he had something of an unusual
nature on his mind and so despite all of the work involved in covering every
twist and turn of the crisis, I agreed. And we met about twenty minutes
later at the Occidental Restaurant, which was one of Washington's old
landmarks about two blocks from the White House. We sat at a table for two
up against the wall and it was a rather icy and kind of meeting. Was no
back slapping and no frivolity involved as we sometimes did when we met
before. But ah—he then finally said the situation is very serious and ah—
something has to be done. And I said, well, your government should have
thought of that before it triggered this crisis because what you have done
is total insanity. He said nothing and we ordered and I noted that the
gentleman involved, Aleksandr Fomin, we can reveal his name now, seemed
indifferent to the food that he ordered which was a sharp contrast to the
gourmet type attitude that he had when we had had lunch on maybe a dozen
occasions. We said very little and picked at our food and he said,
perhaps there's a way out of this. I said, oh. He said that the Cuban
delegate to UN had mentioned something which ah, should be pursued. I said,
well I had been following the United Nations debate very carefully and I
don't remember that the Cuban delegate had said anything. Incidentally,
later checks showed that the Cuban delegate never said anything of
the kind that he then put forward. He said, what would you think of a
solution to the crisis which would involve first our withdrawing these
missiles from Cuba, and doing this under United Nations inspection. Do you
think that your government would be interested? I said, I was just a
reporter and I didn't know, but it sounded to me, I said, like it was
something that could be discussed. He then went on to say that could I
check urgently with my high friends in the administration. And on this we
didn't have to play any games because he knew that I was a personal friend
of the President and that as diplomatic correspondent for ABC News, I had
virtually instant access to Secretary of State Rusk, if it was needed. At
that time I was the only reporter who had covered all of Secretary Rusk's
overseas trips so that we were on a first name basis. I said, well, I
didn't know whether I could get to the Secretary of State immediately
because he was very business, very busy covering this same crisis. He said,
please do, please try. It is very urgent and then he gave me two telephone
numbers which I had not ever known about before. One was his private number
at the Embassy, after the switchboard closed down and number two, his
ah—number at home. And he said I must understand that I am to phone him
anytime day or night because much depends on what is to happen next. As I
went back to the State Department in the cab, I got to wondering whether
this meeting was as ah, important as I thought it was at the time because
why would the Russians turn to me to float even a trial balloon and how did
I not know that half a dozen other Soviets in half a dozen other places
were talking to X number of additional people? By the time I arrived in the
pressroom, I had more or less convinced myself that it wasn't as significant
as I thought it was. Just as a precaution, I called a friend of mine in the
FBI and said to him is Fomin important enough for the Soviets to float a
trial balloon or a legitimate proposal for solving the Cuban Missile Crisis?
And he asked why. I said, well I just had lunch with him. He said, you did?
He said ah—the answer to your question is, hell yes. And we would sure like
to know what it was he said. I said, well, I'll pass it along to Roger
Hilsman, who was the then Director of the State Department Intelligence
Operation. So I sat down in my, at my desk in the State Department Press room
and wrote a very brief memo to him of about 100 words. I said, Aleksandr
Fomin at a luncheon which he urgently requested, asked that I check with my
high administration officials about what the US attitude would be to the
following proposition: Soviets would remove all missiles from Cuba
under...two that there would be United Nations inspection. Three, would
US Government then be willing to pledge publically there would be no
invasion of the, of Cuba. I said I did not know, but that perhaps the matter
could be discussed. Period. And I took the memo, which I had just finished
typing up to the sixth floor where Roger Hilsman's office was and he was
just coming out the door as I came up. And I handed him the memo and we
walked down the hall together as he walking to his next meeting and he
stopped and read it, and looked at me and read it a second time. He said,
this is very interesting. He said, where are you going to be the rest of
the day? I said, I'm going to be back down in the pressroom continuing to
cover this thing. He said, well, don't go away. So I went back to work and
after appearing on the ABC television network news that evening, I suddenly
got a telephone call. Incidentally, I didn't mention this during the six
o'clock broadcast. It was on the phone saying, without telling a soul, he
says, get in the car that we have waiting for you directly outside the ABC
studios and come to the State Department, you may be onto something big.
Well, I'd been around as a reporter many years, and I knew that I couldn't
leave in a crisis situation without at least telling my bureau chief where I
was going and approximately why. But I knew he could be trusted. And I asked
him in turn to to phone Jim Hagerty, the former press secretary to President
Eisenhower who was then the new President of ABC news and to give him a
brief fill in. I was taken to the office of the Secretary of State. He came
out of his office in his shirtsleeves and said, John, he says, you may be
something, you may be on to something which is very important. It fits with
something which we think we are picking up at the UN. He said, I want you to
go back to your friend and tell him the following. And he reached into his
pocket and put out—pulled out a yellow legal sized lined piece of paper in
which he had hand written the following: The US G. sees possibilities
in this suggestion and imagines that this matter could be worked out at
the UN with Secretary General U Thant and the Soviet and US
Representatives. But I must emphasis that time is very short. And he then
said if they ask you, if he asks you, where this comes from, you can tell
him that it comes from the highest officials in the United States
government. But he said, try to say nothing else. And on this matter, I
found out later, that the highest officials in the US government was just
that. He had called President Kennedy as soon as my memo hit his desk and
had also discussed it with Defense Secretary McNamara and after hours of
discussion within the administration, they had decided it was an opening
that was well worth following up and thus they turned to me to go ahead and
see Mr. Fomin a second time. I called him from the office of the State
Department Intelligence Chief, Mr. Hilsman and suggested that we meet
immediately in the coffee shop of the Statler Hotel. The reason I chose
the Statler Hotel was that it was only a half a block from the Embassy. And
at that time I figured that a coffee shop would be somewhat deserted and
sure enough, we met there in ten minutes and I repeated the message word for
word and he listened very carefully and then said that...he then, Fomin then
asked me how does he know that this comes from important figures. I said,
well it comes from the highest sources in the United States government. The
highest officials. He said, Mr. Scali, if I were to report what you tell me,
and it did not come from the highest officials in the United States
government, I could be made to look like a fool at a very crucial moment in
history. I said, Mr. Fomin, if I were to lie about this very important
point, I would be the most irresponsible man in history. And I said and I am
not irresponsible. Whereupon he seemed to be satisfied that it was an
authentic message and then he tried something that the Soviets do every now
and then, they raise the ante when they believe they have you hooked. He
said, well, he said, you know, he says this is a very interesting message,
but, he says, if there is to be inspection of the removal of the missiles
from Cuba, why shouldn't there be simultaneous inspection of the coast of
Florida where you have this big mobilization of forces and of some of the
other islands nearby where perhaps there could be which could be the spring
board for an invasion of Cuba even after this? I didn't have any clue as to
what I should say then, but I've covered foreign policy enough to take a
chance and I said, Mr. Fomin, it seems to me that what you are raising is a
terrible complication which might make it impossible for this agreement. I
said the President of the United States could not, in any way, allow Soviet
or United Nations inspectors to roam up and down the coast of Florida during
this particular time because you want to remember the cause of this terrible
crisis is not our mobilization in Florida and elsewhere but the fact that
you, the Soviet Union, have illegally sneaked missiles into Cuba. I said,
that is the source of the problem. And what we are doing in Cuba, what we
are doing in Florida is a counter mobilization which presumably would have
no further purpose if and when you remove the missiles. He tried to argue a
bit and then finally gave up and he said, Mr. Scali, I can assure you that
this information will be relayed immediately to Moscow and to the highest
officials in the Soviet government. Whereupon he got up, he said, we should
be back in touch together. And he picked up the check from the table. We had
had each a cup of coffee. At that time coffee at the Statler Hotel at least
was only fifteen cents a cup. And the total check was 30 cents. And he took
it to the cashier, who at that time was talking to a lady friend, ah—he
waited impatiently for the conversation to end because he clearly didn't
have any change. He had only a five-dollar bill. And the two dear ladies
continued their conversation and they continued their conversation, so
finally, in exasperation, he took the 30 cent check and the five dollar bill
and slapped it on the counter and took off, shot up the steps and went off
to the Soviet Embassy. I had decided that perhaps he was a little excited.
In any event, I went back to the went back to the State Department and
dictated to four different secretaries in relays a full report on this
meeting. And we took it to the Secretary of State, who came out and skimmed
through it and he said, John, he said, you know, he said, this could be the
first important sign that the Soviets want to back off because it fits with
the secret message that we've just received from Khrushchev. We've
translated and are aware of the contents of the first two sections and more
or less have a general idea of what the third section contains. It comes
from a man who is stupefied with anxiety. He said, there's no mention of the
proposal that they are suggesting through you in this message. But, he said,
if you put them side by side, they fit like a glove. He said, there are two
things I want to tell you. He said remember when you report this that
eyeball to eyeball that they blinked first. And secondly, he said, if this
works out, he said, I'm going to give you the biggest dinner any
correspondent has ever been given in the city of Washington. I nodded
appreciatively. Incidentally, as much as I love Dean Rusk, and I think he is
a great man, that was the last time I heard about that dinner. So, he then
turned around to Hilsman who was with us and said, I want your people to
look through this word for word, upside down and inside out to determine
whether there are any hookers in this. But he said offhand, he says, I don't
see any. So, we parted. I went to bed feeling that perhaps that... at a
minimum, that was the end of that.